Acupuncture Could Cool Hot Flashes in Breast Cancer Survivors

Electroacupuncture produced larger placebo and smaller nocebo effects than did gabapentin for treating hot flashes among breast cancer survivors.
A few needle pricks from acupuncture may be enough to cool severe and daily hot flashes for many breast cancer survivors, according to a new study published in the Journal of Clinical Oncology.

Researchers at the Perelman School of Medicine at the University of Pennsylvania found that electroacupuncture — in which needles deliver a weak electrical current — produced larger placebo and smaller nocebo effects than did gabapentin for treating hot flashes among breast cancer survivors. Breast cancer survivors are restricted from taking FDA-approved treatment for hot flashes, such as hormone replacement therapies, because they include estrogen, but the Penn researchers concluded that electroacupuncture may be an effective management treatment.

“These latest results clearly show promise for managing hot flashes experienced by breast cancer survivors through the use of acupuncture, which in previous studies has also been proven to be an effective treatment for joint pain in this patient population,” lead author Jun J. Mao, associate professor of Family Medicine and Community Health, said in a statement.

This randomized controlled trial enrolled 120 breast cancer survivors who reported experiencing multiple hot flashes per day. Participants were randomly assigned to one of four groups, two involving active treatment and the other two placebo. The intervention was carried out over eight weeks.

In the two treatment arms, participants received electroacupuncture twice per week for two weeks and then once weekly, or gabapentin (900 mg) daily. Survivors assigned to one of the placebo groups received either “sham” electroacupuncture, which involved no actual needle penetration or electrical current, or a daily placebo in place of the gabapentin.

Investigators used a hot flash composite score (HFCS) to measure hot flash frequency and severity. At the end of the eight weeks, those in the electroacupuncture group showed the greatest reduction in HFCS (-7.4), followed by the sham acupuncture group, the gabapentin pill group, and the placebo pill group (-5.9 v -5.2 v -3.4, respectively).

The electroacupuncture group and the sham electroacupuncture group experienced 47.8 percent and 45 percent improvement in hot flashes, respectively. Improvement for the gabapentin group was 39.4 percent and 22.3 percent with placebo.

Both acupuncture groups reported fewer adverse side effects than the pill groups.

“We found that acupuncture elicited a greater placebo response than did pills, consistent with observations in studies of pain,” the authors wrote. “Although not completely understood, the enhanced placebo effect seen in acupuncture may be a combination of positive expectancy, patient–provider interaction, active patient engagement, relaxation, and light sensory stimulation by the sham needling.”

The groups were evaluated again four months after therapy ended to measure the durability of the treatment effects. Researchers found that survivors who received electroacupuncture had the best long-term effect (-8.5), followed by the sham acupuncture group (-6.1), placebo pill group (-4.6) and the gabapentin group (-2.8).

Electroacupuncture produced a 25 percent greater reduction in HFCS compared with the sham version, but the authors noted that their preliminary findings need to be confirmed in larger studies with long-term follow-up.

Talk about this article with other patients, caregivers, and advocates in the Breast Cancer CURE discussion group.
Special Feature
Share Your Art
Related Articles
The Logistics of Multigene Panel Testing in Breast Cancer
Generally, health insurance covers the cost of genetic testing recommended by a physician. However, some patients who had BRCA testing in the past have had trouble getting reimbursed for a follow-up panel test. The outof- pocket cost for a single panel test can be up to $5,000, although lower-cost tests are available.
Exploring Genetic Differences in Men's Breast Cancer
The genetic differences that distinguish men’s breast cancers may lead to new diagnosis and treatment options.
Cancer Stress and Coping With Change
Cancer survivor notices difficulty with changes and transitions since cancer.
Related Videos
Mapping Out the Care Team in Cancer Survivorship
Patricia J. Goldsmith, CEO of CancerCare, discusses the importance of coordinating between health care professionals as a patient moves into survivorship and converts to treating cancer as a chronic illness.
Angela Fishbaugh on Discovering Your Story and Skills
Angela Fishbaugh, author of "Angela's Decision," discusses how to discover your skills and story within. 
Sam Smith Explains Cognitive Behavioral Therapy for Patients With Breast Cancer
Sam Smith, University of Leeds, explains cognitive behavioral therapy for patients with breast cancer.
//For side ad protocol