Partnering Up for Skin Examinations Helps Chances of Identifying Melanoma
Early detection of new or recurrent melanoma can be aided by checking skin with a partner who has been trained to identify concerning moles on the body.
BY Katie Kosko
PUBLISHED June 30, 2016
Performing skin self-examinations with a partner can help with early detection of new or recurrent melanoma, according to a study conducted by researchers at Northwestern Medicine in Chicago and published online in the journal JAMA Dermatology.
A total of 494 patients with a history of melanoma participated with a partner. The pairs in the study were trained on how to identify concerning moles on the body.
“We delivered the intervention in three ways,” said June K. Robinson, research professor of dermatology and lead author on the study. “We delivered it with in-person training sessions with my research assistants using a PowerPoint, in a workbook that the two read in an office together and with tablets that they looked at and then they could discuss whatever they were reading or seeing.”
Pairs were randomized to one of four trial arms: control (no intervention), training with a workbook, in-person training or training with tablet. Informative sessions ranged from 20 to 45 minutes in length and the patient-partner pairs on any of the three intervention arms learned how to recognize change in the border, color and diameter of moles. Together they then gave the mole a score using a three-point system: 1 meaning normal, 2 meaning ‘unsure’ and 3 meaning abnormal.
Robinson and her team reinforced the skills in four-month intervals over a two-year period. At each visit, data were collected through self-reported surveys that both patients and partners filled out separately, in different rooms. Both patients and partners received $20 for each assessment completed.
Among all 494 patients, 69 melanomas were identified. Sixty-six were new melanomas and three patients had in-transit metastasis.
Patient-partner pairs receiving an intervention (395 pairs) identified 43 of the melanomas successfully. However, patient-partner pairs in the control group were not able to identify any melanomas. Physicians identified melanoma in 16 different patients.
Robinson told CURE the study’s findings can be beneficial in two ways. First, skin self-examinations can decrease anxiety and reduce the number of physician visits because patients have better control and understanding of their body.
“Early in the diagnosis of melanoma, they are very anxious about every boo-boo being another melanoma and so they ring the phone and try to get an appointment with the doctor to be seen immediately,” she said. “If we give them a system that they can use to enable and empower themselves, then the anxiety level starts to decrease because they can make rational decisions about how fast they have to go see the doctor.”
The second benefit is getting the patients — who think they don’t have to worry anymore because they’re five years out from treatment — to do their own skin checks with partners. Robinson said this is crucial because the risk of developing another melanoma continues for at least an additional ten years.
The idea of studying skin self-examinations with a partner came to life from an experience Robinson had with a male patient. The steel worker, of Irish-decent, worked outside for years and had a concerning mole on his back. While Robinson was explaining to him what to look for in the future, he said he didn’t care and to told her to “talk to [his] wife.”
It dawned on her at that moment that partners may be the best way to get people to actually check their skin.
To move this study forward, Robinson hopes to make the program deliverable by an app to smartphones. It would include all the important information to determine a concerning mole. If a person felt as if the mole was peculiar, she suggested taking a photo and sending it to her to examine. The app, she feels, could promote better behaviors, since it is easily accessible in a person’s pocket.
“A lot of younger people who have melanoma, they’re working people, they don’t want to take off from work to go to the doctor over nothing,” said Robinson. “And the older people, they don’t want to travel through traffic to get to the doctor’s office for nothing. So, the reassurance they can take an appropriate image with a smartphone by its accessibility and ease of use can take the program a notch up.”